75 Comments
User's avatar
HM's avatar

Kingston Trip, MTa

Expand full comment
HM's avatar

Anything Danny Kaye sang in ‘The Inspector General’ puts me in fits of giggles, can’t breathe.

Expand full comment
Anne Elizabeth Bowerman's avatar

We are very fond of Spike Jones in this house! In particular, the All Girl Band. Puts us in stitches every time. They aren’t too shabby when it comes to playing it straight, either. Their rendition of the main theme from ‘Laura’ is beautifully done.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Just found out Spike Jones did his own rendition of Bizet's 'Carmen'.............

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5mE_Kek45o

Long been a big fan of Barney Kessel's jazz version...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9aFv7IwMes

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

And regards silliness generally, have people seen the films (Mockumentory's) done by some of the same people who did Spinal Tap...

A Mighty Wind (folk music reunion festival)

Best In Show

For Your Consideration

Waiting For Guffman

Expand full comment
Matthew D'Antuono's avatar

I don’t know if he wrote any of his own music, but Victoria Borge certainly nails silliness when it comes to music!!

E.g. https://youtu.be/dKeqaDSjy98?si=3qenvzdV0m9i50Wi

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Oh, so fantastic...and I don't think it's easy to "make a mess" of things so perfectly.....

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Oh, Matthew! He was marvelous, and the King of Silliness -- but very talented, indeed. The Great Dane! I've been saving a particularly silly OLD video of him from his youth for just the right moment. Thanks for that clip from the Dean Martin Show. I know I haven't seen that one, and am looking forward to it!

Expand full comment
Matthew D'Antuono's avatar

How about “Boy Named Sue” by Johnny Cash! And the lyrics were by that great classical poet Shel Silverstein

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Ha! Yes, indeed. That's a contender for the right day here, silly or otherwise. I didn't know that Shel Silverstein wrote the lyircs!

Expand full comment
Matthew D'Antuono's avatar

Apparently, Cash and Silverstein were friends. John Carter Cash, Johnny‘s son, included a picture of the two of them together, along with a couple of other friends, in a book about his father.

Expand full comment
Amy De Rosa's avatar

Mares Eat Oats, Polly Wolly Doodle, Turkey in The Straw.

These came to mind as “sillier” than my original suggestion of the Jimmy Soul song, which is maybe not silly but more comic sarcasm. Silly means “nonsense” and just for fun.🤔

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Oh, my dad used to sing Mairzy Doats to me as a kid, and I loved it. Dad LOVED all novelty songs! He also used to sing me The Purple People Eaters! I posted an incredibly silly version of Liberace doing Turkey in the Straw a couple of years ago. And of course the folk songs are full of silliness. I love Polly Wolly Doodle. In fact we call our puppy Molly Wolly Doodle Doggie!

Expand full comment
Chad's avatar

Yep, my almost-4-year-old daughter agrees. Spike was on stage for less than a minute before she exclaimed, "He's silly!" She proceeded to enjoy the rest of the video with much giggling. The headless musicians were particularly exciting for her. 🤪

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Chad, that's great! And we all need to keep that childlike joy.. in silly things. My father used to sing me silly songs when I was a child, and I loved that! There's more Spike Jones audios on Youtube, but I think you miss the best of it if you don't SEE as well as hear that act!

Expand full comment
Mrswu's avatar

I am reading Chesterton's The Flying Inn just now, which contains some jolly songs of silliness. Do you think humans require a certain amount of bonafide silliness, that there is a MDR for it? I loved the Spike Jones bit, though my brain keeps wanting to call him Spike Lee. Now THAT'S silly!😁

Expand full comment
Anthony Esolen's avatar

You're right -- I keep having to dissociate him from Spike Lee and Quincy Jones ...

Expand full comment
Mrswu's avatar

Now there's a merry mash-up medley!😂

Expand full comment
Amy De Rosa's avatar

Same! Spike Lee! I think that may be my confusion.

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

It was before the time of most of us on W&S, but Spike Jones was a regular phenomenon in popular music of the 40's and 50's. He kept trying after that, but later popular music didn't lend itself to his "treatment."

Expand full comment
Mrswu's avatar

Because later pop music was already too silly for parody!😉

Expand full comment
Mark Osborne's avatar

I loved the parody of musical history and the general innocence of the fun. It isn't making fun at anyone else's expense, as parodies can often be, except maybe Josef Stalin, and I'm not wasting any sympathy on him.

Spike had a face that cartoonists must have loved to draw caricatures of.

I must be entirely too serious. The only silly performers that come to mind, and I can't say I'm a devotee of either, are the performances of the Canadian Brass (tariff-free version, please) and Leon Redbone's version of Froggie Went a-Courtin'.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

The BEST version of 'Baby, It's Cold Outside is from Elf.......Leon Redbone and Zooey Deschanel (who actually has at least one full length CD out).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bxyb7nce9-g

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

I agree about Spike's face! And there are so many silly folk songs. We could do a Substack on those alone, haha!

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Mark, in WWII time, nobody was wasting any sympathy for Stalin. Think of Werner Klemperer doing Hogan's Heroes in the 60's. He had to flee Nazi Germany and was very happy to make the Nazis look like imbeciles!

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

And his father is the conductor of what is, in my opinion, the finest recording of Beethovan's 9th Symphony.

Expand full comment
Anthony Esolen's avatar

I remember there were silly songs that children learned and sang, like the one that has this for its refrain:

O Dunderbeck, O Dunderbeck, how could you be so mean

To ever have invented the sausage-meat machine!

Now all the neighbors' cats and dogs will never more be seen,

For they've been ground to sausage-meat in Dunderbeck's machine!

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

And all the silly songs sung around the campfire while in the Scouts (you know, when the Boy Scouts really were the Boy Scouts).

Expand full comment
Mark Osborne's avatar

Yes, where do such silly, slightly macabre, songs come from? How are they transmitted from one age group to the next?

For example,

"Great green gobs of greasy, grimy, gopher's guts,

concentrated turtle meat,

dirty little birdie's feet . . .

That's what we like to eat!"

This one was popular and sung with gusto among the boys in my neighborhood, a housing area for US Army dependents on Okinawa in the 1960s. I blame the military influence, or maybe children's summer camps.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Boys trying to gross out girls???

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Hahaa! That's a new one on me. It touches on the genre of "Dark Humor," which I used to do a teeny bit of in my college lit course on "American Humor." You find it in the works of Flannery O'Connor, for example, but also in the humor of Mark Twain and of the stories of Davy Crockett and the old "southwest," when the frontier meant Texas and Missouri.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Mark Twain's short stories are brilliant...and even having read most of them many times, they still make me laugh....

Favorite--The Facts In The Case Of The Great Beef Contract

Expand full comment
Mark Osborne's avatar

Yes, Mark, I agree. I fondly remember Twain's the "McWilliamses and the Burglar Alarm."

Expand full comment
sukey jamison's avatar

we loved Spike Jones. We would play his "best of" with our children, so we all got a big laugh!

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

He was absolutely GREAT at what he did!

Expand full comment
Steve Terenzio's avatar

Would you say "Don't Let the Rain Come Down" qualifies?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDnDVlTtP6Y

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Makes me think of the Phil Collins song, 'The Roof Is Leaking'

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sm9OYVlAr2I

Expand full comment
Steve Terenzio's avatar

Nice song, thanks. It got me searching for a summary of his long and varied career - acting, band member, and solo - I hadn't realized just how prolific he was in all time record sales.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

He does a terrific job on the Motown classic, My Girl too...

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Wow, Steve! To tell the truth, I call that sublime folk music! And yes, there is a great deal of the silly in folk music, very good-hearted and human stories. I recall hearing that song as a kid! Thanks for bring back something I haven't thought of in 50 years! Tony and our daughter are out buying plants .. but I'm going to share this with them tonight.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Silliness.....but also strikingly wonderful........"The Kiffness" started with a manipulated video of a cat...he began adding bits...then he began getting contacted from all over the world by people who want to collaborate with him.....much of what he does remains silly, but also an example of what the world could be like with peoples coming together...He has tons of shorts, with muscians from everywhere joining in .......

The Kiffness https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8lXySB8QC4

The Kiffness Numnum Cat International mashup https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GArzu9ttQ0M&list=RDEMg0UOqcBbNDdesP7kegtIEg&index=2

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S61ENc51Z1Q

Not silly, but sweet...

The Kiffness Every Day I need The Blood of Jesus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7cUuVUo11c

Expand full comment
John O'Brien, Jr.'s avatar

Some silly Beatles songs, which come to mind: Maxwell's Silver Hammer, Her Majesty, Bungalow Bill, Rocky Raccoon, Yellow Submarine, Octopus's Garden.

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

Yes! Maswell's Silver Hammer is a silly song in the style of rather "dark" humor! I love all of these playful songs!

Expand full comment
John O'Brien, Jr.'s avatar

A silly song, in an off-the-wall way, obscure now, but which got a lot of air-time in 1966, was “They’re Coming to Take Me Away, Ha-Haaa!”, by Napoleon IV (maybe the singer's only song). Incredibly, it reached No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100.

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Watch what you call silly......I live in an Octopus's Garden LOL

Expand full comment
Debra Esolen's avatar

In the shade??

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Naturally.....not a big fan of being in the sun.....

Expand full comment
Mark Maxfield's avatar

Some silliness from Bollywood films...

3 Idiots--All Izz Well........ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7PzwOiW8-n0&list=LL&index=9

3 Idiots--Zoobi Doobi....... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gITHJlFqXCc&list=LL&index=10

Like Stars On Earth--Bum Bum Bole........ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJ1NIIdHhXs

Expand full comment